I went down a deep rabbit hole (and I'm still falling). It started out with the idea of trying to compile #Uxntal into LLVM IR (and maybe WASM). Now I've jumped ships mid-course and changed to C as a target; I will probably, out of sheer perverseness, do Fortran as well. So this is decompilation of a stack-based assembly language into a non-stack-based higher-level language.

It's one of these "how hard can it be?" things.

The answer in short is, it's impossible; but there are degrees of approximation, and they are increasingly difficult. So it's a lot of fun.

#compilers
#decompilation

My compiler now works on the Uxntal "Hello, world" so I guess that's it, job done ^_^

Let me introduce "nito", a proof-of-concept compiler from #Uxntal to C.

You can find it at codeberg.org/wimvanderbauwhede.

I might still do an actual LLVM IR backend, and will almost certainly do Fortran as it is too good to let pass.

#compilers

Follow

@wim_v12e

> on_reset_while: 1; /* label needs statement */

That's horrible. I love it! :D

@pixelherodev 🤣
That's me being lazy, because I use combined declarations + statements and that is not a valid target.

@wim_v12e I'm aware! :)

I've written some transpilers targeting C for fun; my solution was, more convolutedly, to track whether a label was needed :P

@pixelherodev Ah, I should probably do too. But laziness is a virtue 😄

@wim_v12e It's a matter of axioms, really: do you intend for the output of your transpiler to be machine code that happens to be valid input to a C compiler, or to be C language code?

If the former, the "lazy" approach is actually the *correct* one. You shouldn't optimize for human readability for the C, because it's basically trash. Its only purpose is to be lowered to QBE/GIMPLE/LLVM/SDIR/etc and from there to machine code, which will be more readable than the C anyways.

@pixelherodev I prefer the former, that is why I'll probably go to LLVM IR directly (but after I've done Fortran ^_^).

@pixelherodev By the way thanks for looking at it in that level of detail!

@wim_v12e Well I wasn't going to comment _without_ at least reading the README! >_>

@pixelherodev You're way ahead of lots of people on the internet with that attitude :-D

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Fosstodon

Fosstodon is an English speaking Mastodon instance that is open to anyone who is interested in technology; particularly free & open source software.