Follow

Guys,
I need a Linux Distro for portable use. (like Puppy Linux)
It must be persistent.
I have a 16GB flash drive.

What is the best?

- I have tried Ubuntu 19.10 with persistent storage. It works but that's not what I need.

@optimuspnj

What problema did you have with puppy? Helps to know to recommend you a new one

@wuwei No no, don't misunderstand me. I just searching for another one. Puppy Linux is great.

I got a problem with GCC. I installed GCC, but it didn't recognized as a command in Terminal.

I really appreciate your toot. Thank you. ❤

@optimuspnj

Well then Knoppix or MX are also some options

@optimuspnj Most Linux distros can be installed on a 16GB flash drive and be usable. What specifically are you looking for?

@matt I tried Ubuntu 19.10 with Persistent support. I liked it, but it caused some problems. Such as not detecting screen brightness, Not opening Chromium after installation etc.

Thank you so much for the reply. ❤ Can you suggest a distro? A Debian based one?

@Apitronics It will do, But I don't know how to install Debian with persistent support. Is it possible?

Thank you for your reply. ❤

@optimuspnj It seems to be possible since Debian 9 at least.

A quick search on the Internet give us a protocol. I don't know if this website is still maintained, but :

fabbnet.net/Live_Persistent.ht

@optimuspnj I have an arch install like this, not much needs changing beyond setting journalctl not to persist logs to disk, and using `libeatmydata`.

@optimuspnj As other stated, it's hard to recommend something. Honestly I figured puppy would be awesome for this, as it's lightweight and I'm assuming install it to a flash drive. There is Tiny Core also, but not sure how portable that would be.

@jordan31 Thank you for the reply. ❤ I'll stick with Puppy then.

@optimuspnj you can take a look at my mkdebusb script which allows you to create an usb flash drive with persistance from a Debian live media. notabug.org/LiohMoeller/mkdebu - It requires a Debian hosts system of the same version. Use it with the --install-dependencies parameter on the first run and then read the help with -h. It allows also restore of existing persistance to port it to another device. If you want to change the keyboard layout / locale, you have to do it in the script for now.

@optimuspnj and depending on your usb flash drive type, don't exect too much from anything. I recommend something like this, but I guess it's not what you have for the moment. Just give it a try. Maybe not with the GNOME ISOs. If you need Firmware, choose from here: cdimage.debian.org/cdimage/uno

@optimuspnj if you face any issues, just let me know.

@optimuspnj Try out Porteus. It's a bit different from other distros and perfect for this use case.

I have played with it briefly and found it interesting. A friend swears by it.

porteus.org/

It's a bit slow at updating and the current release is a year old, but the packages come from slackware and should be possible to upgrade.

@optimuspnj hello, your post appears on my timeline thanks to #FOSS tag.

Why persistent? In my experience, persistent mode is slow. You can install any GNU/Linux distro to flash drive if you want. I recommend EXT2 filesystem for that. Just select bootloader to be installed in that drive and run the OS everywhere.

Good luck!

@ademalsasa I'm looking for persistent distro because...

My laptop was died two days ago, I was using an eight year old laptop. You know how it feels like when IT guy lost his machine. 😌

My cousin has a laptop but he is using Windows which I hate the most. Somehow, I have to do my studies and stuff. I was unable to buy a laptop so sooner, because I'm a student... So... I'm ended up like this.

Anyway thank you so much for the reply sir! ❤

@optimuspnj I wish you to have new laptop. Ah for mentioned problem, it's still better to install the OS to flash drive rather than persistence, as you can do it with a Windows laptop. Good luck.

@optimuspnj i normally use slax in this situation. no idea whether its the best though

@twee I didn't find a settings app in Slax. Is it normal?

@optimuspnj no idea. i don't use such a system very often at all.

@optimuspnj
I use Debian 10 persistent live on a daily basis for work, since I'm forced to use Win10 on that machine but I prefer to know what my computer is doing. Works great, just few minor issues, easily solvable.

I tried Puppy and it works great, also flashed into some USB for friends as a gift.
Xubuntu is quite OK but on some machines is not so snappy and gets very slow, same for Lubuntu.

@optimuspnj I used Ubuntu 16.04 on a usb flash drive once, it worked pretty well. I would recommend Ubuntu MATE 16.04 though.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Fosstodon

Fosstodon is an English speaking Mastodon instance that is open to anyone who is interested in technology; particularly free & open source software.