Every day it becomes a little more clear to me why we *need* GNOME OS

The desktop/distro separation just doesn't work. There's no clean way to square the interests of platforms and distributions (because every distribution thinks of itself as a platform, when they really aren't).

This isn't GNU/Linux specific either, Android has the same problem. Every OEM wants to be Apple, but doesn't want to do the work of maintaining a full vertical platform.

This incentivizes them to make decisions that are actively user-hostile (such as pushing out updates more slowly because they need to update their custom UI stuff).

We see the same dynamic playing out on the GNU/Linux desktop: Ubuntu, Fedora, Pop OS etc. are pretending to be platforms, but they're not.

This results in a situation where everyone is trying to do campy "value-add" features, and pushing their brand in users' faces. It's why atrocities like the Fedora logo extension, and developer-hostile custom system stylesheets are a thing even though everyone knows these are bad ideas.

Of course it's a little different on Android, because Google has long made Nexus/Pixel devices, which ship a clean version of the platform without OEM "improvements".

But even on the free desktop there are examples of this: elementaryOS is famously vertical by design, Budgie has Solus, and even KDE has Neon. We're the only platform that you *can't* get without going through a distributor.

Bottom line: We need GNOME OS, and we need it now.


@tbernard Just filling in a point here that we in the KDE community really want to make certain is clear: KDE neon is a project which has a certain niche. It is not "our distro". A vast majority of KDE devs do not use it, or work on it at all.

Sign in to participate in the conversation

Fosstodon is a Mastodon instance that is open to anyone who is interested in technology; particularly free & open source software.