I would tend to agree with that. My personal reason why ortholinear feels better is for touch typing.
One day I basically decided to go all-in and learn Dvorak and touch typing on my new Ergodox EZ (ortho split keyboard). Right now I'm typing this on a regular staggered keyboard and I can tell you my left hand is having a hard time finding the right (!) keys on the bottom row.
Ortho is much easier to place your fingers by feel.
Ooh nice, I got to wave 009!
But Zen Typing is actually a game I made
So any feedback is appreciated :)
@Naughtylus @arran @sotolf @hund Ooooh, so it is a game to learn the abstract skill of touch typing. That's a cool concept! It might be useful to experiment the feel of touch-typing. Sadly I can not experiment it, since I have touch typed since I can remember (lessons as child). I'll keep it handy for people who could find it interesting.
@Naughtylus @robby Could you share criticism of Dvorak? I have read some Dvorak vs Colemak posts and Dvorak seems better in all ways for my personal use case. Pros of Colemak seem to be more similarity with qwerty and same position of ZXCV for keybindings, both of which are irrelevant for me. Pros of Dvorak are no qwerty inspiration and more comfy movement keys.
Honesty, that guy just convinced me haha I don't know why.
Next layout I try is the Workman layout.
@arran tagging you as well, since you seem to be wanting to learn a new layout.
For I just use the arrow keys they're right under my indexes and middles on my ergodox.
Generally speaking I prefer my fingers extending and curling to them going sideways, but that's a very minor inconvenience, and I do enjoy Dvorak.
@Naughtylus @robby @arran Haha, not much against Dvorak. Also I will use the Spanish version, which swaps h and r and keeps the symbols from qwerty (which I actually hate). Don't know, don't know. There is a ton of debate in all directions on the web. Whem I have a QMK keyboard I guess I will tweak until I have something that works for me.
Yeah I wouldn't fret too much over it, since you can basically choose your own layout key by key, just go with the one you find the most elegant (maybe you like how dvorak puts all the vowels on the left home row) and then you can tweak it when you find weird finger moves. Especially since you won't be typing English all the time, the letter frequencies won't match.
Fosstodon is an English speaking Mastodon instance that is open to anyone who is interested in technology; particularly free & open source software.