So if they value a consistent user experience, then Signal is right to be concerned.
Of course, when your consistent experience is "down" that's definitely not great.
@Hawk1291 Yeah, it was a darn shame when they stopped federating. My hope is with XMPP and Matrix, though I'm a little annoyed that there are two federated networks. At least they bridge nicely.
@Hawk1291 I really hope we one day see something as secure and easy to use as Signal but decentralized (that does not exist today).
That being said, that decentralized systems run by small associations and individuals would be able to cope with and addition of 40M+ users in 10 days is unsure (at best).
Here is a nice discussion about Signal versus decentralized protocols https://matrix.org/blog/2020/01/02/on-privacy-versus-freedom/
Maybe they are talking about reliable in terms of security (and not user experience). Maybe not everyone is close or has the skills to keep a signal server perfectly secure.
@breizhux Expect moxie helped facebook's privacy whashing scam (whatsapp) for money, without thinking facebook's shady behaviour might hurt his (or Signal crypto protocol's) reputation.
But did everything he could to fight federation and third-party clients without google's crap, making it difficult to have Signal clients chat just work out on the box on on ungooglised androids (no google api, not even micros @Hawk1291 - 1/2
Yes, but that's another problem... and langis was created to provide a signal without Google...
Moreover, I saw that signal no longer integrates the Google analytics service (according to exodus) ! This shows some improvement.
And from a security point of view, no other messaging system has proven itself as far as I know ...
@breizhux As far as I know, some XMPP clients support OMEMO crypto.
I know about Langis. But it's doesn't solve the problem, Which is Moxie being an asshole to third party clients' dev.
As far as I know, Langis relies only on one person, for one platform (google-free android). If Moxie weren't an asshole, maybe non-android Linux phones users (Sailfish, Ububtouch, PureOS, maybe even maemo-leste in the future, @Hawk1291 - 1/4
or whatever) could have, or could get (well-maintained, and up-to-date) clients¹ for Signal. Or at least, chances for that to happen would be higher. Moxie clearly doesn't give a fuck about non-android users. Not many devs would want to get involved with Signal, and of Moxie's "asshole-itude" is one of the reasons.
Signal* but don't want to give them your phone number, or want to use "one or multiple pseudonymes, independent from other PII", or just doesn't want to restart from scratch when you change your phone number ? The answer is, like usual, "If you want to use it otherwise than what I decided, go fuck yourself"
It's actually the exact opposite. If Signal was decentralised, such an exodus would either have lead to people flocking to a big "main" instance, which would not have taken the load.
This instance could have stopped accepting newcomers(like mastodon), but that would just have lead to less people actually making the switch, or them flooding smaller instances which can't take the load either.
The newcomers are non tech savvy. No new instances would have appeared to take the load.
@dreeg @Hawk1291 Here are some thoughts on centralized vs federated messengers. Matrix has 35% of users on the default instance which is a good number and seems to be going down. https://matrix.org/blog/2020/01/02/on-privacy-versus-freedom
@Hawk1291 I never thought moxie's argument for centralisation made sense.
The convenience of hashing all phone numbers to grow contact lists more easily doesn't smell right to me.
Iexpect in a few years we'll find out that the US-funded US-operated US-hosted signal has a few carefully selected data leaks, just enough info to allow NSA etc to siphon off the "social graph of signal".
That being said, threema & signal are both awesome and far better than the ad-funded alternatives.
@stunder I use a variety of messengers. Matrix, wire, xmpp, signal. Matrix is my favorite. I tried Session a while back. I think they have made some major improvements since then and wouldn't mind giving it another try. It wasn't very reliable at the time and multi clients were an issue too iirc.
Fosstodon is an English speaking Mastodon instance that is open to anyone who is interested in technology; particularly free & open source software.